Oakland police chief, mayor respond to spate of shootings that left 4 dead in 24 hours

Howard Jordan condemns the recent spate of violence in Oakland at a press conference Monday.

Howard Jordan condemns the recent spate of violence in Oakland at a press conference Monday.

Police Chief Howard Jordan and Mayor Jean Quan held a press conference Monday afternoon to condemn the recent spate of violence that resulted in four homicides in Oakland last Friday.

Traffic slowed on International Boulevard as dozens of TV news crews gathered in the shadow of the Oakland Police Department’s Mobile Command Unit. Jordan and Quan took turns addressing the crowd in front of a memorial painting dedicated to Carlos Nava, the three-year-old boy who was killed in August, 2011, when a stray bullet struck him.

“We’ve had six murders already this year compared to two last year at this time,” Jordan said.  “That is simply unacceptable in this city.”

The most recent string of killings began around 2:30 pm on Friday, January 11. The OPD responded to a call on the 2300 block of E. 17th Street that a 22-year-old unidentified male had been shot multiple times. The victim later died at the hospital.

Just thirty minutes later, at 3:04, police responded to a call at Canon Avenue and Wellington Street, and found a second victim shot to death, a 30-year-old Stockton resident they identified as Larry Lovette.

At 4:15, the OPD responded to a third call about gunshots, this time on the 3400 block of West Street. No victims were found, but one victim, later identified as Eddiebo Rodriguez, was able to get himself to the hospital, where he later died.

The last shooting took place later that night, at 8:15, on the 9400 block of Hillside, where 17-year-old high school senior Ken Harbin was killed.

Jordan said that two of the four murders were associated with two feuding groups who police believe have been responsible for as many as 90 percent of the murders, robberies and shootings that have taken place in Oakland over the last six to eight months. Jordan declined to give details about the shootings because the police are still looking for suspects, but he did say that OPD has learned that the most recent violence was triggered by the death of a young woman.

Although he didn’t provide details about the two groups police believe are responsible for much of the violence, Jordan said the OPD knows “who the people are who are perpetuating this violence. It is probably about 1 to 2 percent of the population.” He said it is now his department’s job to gather “enough intelligence, enough evidence, and enough data” to ensure that those people can be brought to justice so that they do not return to the streets and cause more violence. “We know who the bad guys are. We are focused on getting them,” he said.

Jordan said one person has been arrested in relation to the shootings this weekend, and another search warrant has been issued. Jordan said he has called on US Marshalls to assist in the search for that suspect. In addition, Jordan said, “Since Friday we have recovered 11 weapons that are directly or indirectly involved in incidences from this weekend and from previous murders.” The recovered weapons were mostly handguns, but they also included some AK-47s, according to Jordan.

Before attending the press conference, Jordan visited two scenes where murders took place on Friday, one at the 3400 block of West Street, and the other on Seminary Avenue, in order to talk to victims’ neighbors and community members about the recent violence. “It was a very humbling experience for me,” Jordan said, “because I got to hear firsthand about the fear that they have, and it’s real fear.” Jordan said that several residents had recounted for him the way they had reacted to the gunfire. “People want justice and peace and they want this violence to stop,” he said.

Jordan said he is working on a redeployment plan to temporarily get more Oakland police officers on the streets, as well as an agreement to add fifteen Sherriff’s Department deputies to patrol in Oakland. Jordan said these were only temporary measures because “We don’t have the luxury right now to make this long term.” He added, “We are looking at ways to impact crime with our current resources.” Jordan also said that additional officers will be on the street this weekend, but did not give a specific number.

Quan reaffirmed Jordan’s statements, adding that Oakland has been “acting as if it is in a state of emergency for a while.”

“Each time I have asked the governor for additional support he has given it to us,” Quan said, adding that she will be making a request for additional, unspecified federal support in the coming weeks with Congresswoman Barbara Lee.

“I think the city has reached its tolerance level,” Quan said in reference to the recent spate of homicides. She said she plans on “pulling together a summit of educators, nonprofits, business community, ministers, and law enforcement, to really focus on the most dangerous and most violence, which appears to be mostly juveniles.”

Quan also referred to Vice President Joe Biden’s report on gun violence, which is due out on January 15, and is expected to outline new gun control measures aimed at curbing the availability of many kinds of weapons. “The bottom line is that so many of these guns were not sold in Oakland, were probably not even sold in the state California,” Quan said, referring to the 11 weapons seized by the OPD. “We have to stop these guns from coming into our city and we cannot do that without an national, universal series of reforms.”

Quan said disputes between young people didn’t always “end with a dozen murders.” But, she said, because of the “availability of guns, we have disputes between people that are very young who are totally out of control.” She called for politicians to support Biden’s report and findings.

Newly elected District 5 councilmember Noel Gallo gave an impassioned speech urging the community to retake their streets and provide safety for the children of Oakland. “This is a call for the community to get back to the great city Oakland was. Let’s quit making excuses and demonstrate our love and support for our kids, the future of Oakland,” Gallo said.

Jordan ended his comments by noting that it was “the eve of Martin Luther King’s birthday” and quoting the civil rights leader: “Violence brings only temporary victories. Violence, by creating many more social problems than it solves, never brings permanent peace.”

“My pledge today is to work with the community and work with our law enforcement partners to end the senseless violence that is taking place in our city,” Jordan said.

6 Comments

  1. Samantha

    Also on Friday night, there was a massive shoot out near 8th and Peralta. I guess it didn’t make the news because no one was injured or killed. I know about it because I live a couple blocks away and the shots lasted long enough for us to feel compelled to get down on the floor in order to avoid any possible stray bullets. Peace out Oakland. Rents are getting too high, people from SF are getting pushed into Oakland, therefore pushing most people out of Oakland further into the East Bay. Oakland has so much going for it, if only people could actually feel safe here.

    • OPD’s assertion that “police believe have been responsible for as many as 90 percent of the murders, robberies and shootings that have taken place in Oakland over the last six to eight months” is not credible for several reasons, least of which is that it follows last year’s retracted claim that most of the city’s crime was concentrated in 100 blocks.

      A. OPD by it’s own admission has an abysmally low rate of identifying who committed crimes, something below 45%. So how could they say with any certainty that 90% were committed by these two gangs?

      B. If OPD was so sure that 90% of all the serious crimes in the city were committed by two gangs, why didn’t they quickly dedicate most of the police force to investigating these two gangs so dozens of lives could have been saved?

      • “Oakland backs down on crime war figures

        High, not that high

        Questioned about the statement Tuesday, Jordan’s chief of staff, Sgt. Chris Bolton, said, “It’s an extremely high percentage, not 90.”

        He said 58 percent of homicides that occurred from January to September of last year happened in East Oakland. Of those, he said, as many as 65 percent were associated with street groups and gangs.

        “It’s obvious that group and gang violence drives the core of our homicide rate,” Bolton said, “and it’s deserving of attention regardless of what the exact number is.”

        A spokesman for Mayor Jean Quan, Sean Maher, said, “The exact percentage isn’t as important as the fact that these two groups are responsible for a huge percentage of the violence that’s plaguing the city. The exact figure isn’t as important as what we’re going to do to stop them.”
        Second backtrack

        This isn’t the first time an Oakland leader has had to backtrack after making a sweeping statement about crime in the city. Last summer, Quan admitted she had, for several months, erroneously claimed that 90 percent of the city’s homicides and shootings occurred in 100 of the city’s 6,560 blocks.

        Robert Weisberg, a Stanford law professor who co-directs the Stanford Criminal Justice Center, said it was clear Jordan’s statement was “either a mistake or just hyperbole. He couldn’t possibly have meant that.”

        Weisberg said it was plausible that a drastic, short-term spike in killings could be explained by a specific social situation such as a gang dispute.

        Read more: http://www.sfgate.com/crime/article/Oakland-backs-down-on-crime-war-figures-4197189.php#ixzz2I6nvKw36

        • Rob

          Wow, it took only one day this time for the true numbers to come out. Strange how the Quan administration is always so out of touch on crime figures.

          65% of 58% is 38%. Not exactly 90% but close, right?

          In a related article about protests at city council regarding “stop and frisk” Bratton:


          Jim Dexter, a longtime community policing advocate, spoke out in favor of Bratton’s hire. But he also said that increasing the police force, which will continue to decline for at least two months because of attrition, is the city’s top priority.

          “It’s a shame for this city to have a police force of 600 or less,” said Dexter.

          To that, someone in the crowd said, “Let it drop to zero.”

          The latter person is Quan’s constituency.

  2. Rob

    This is more nonsense from Mayor Quan. Her approach to city management is “principles over reality”. More youth programs (note her emphasis over and over on the purported age of the shooters/victims) is not the answer.

    We need a city government that is supportive of the police department while also being tough negotiators on the police/fire budgets. We can’t afford cops at their current salaries and pensions.

    We need more police, at least until we’re in line with the per capita rate of SF and SJ.

    We DON’T need empty statements, guesses, pleas, and posturing from the mayor’s office.

    I’ve lived here for 13 years and my best guess is that Oakland officials want to be Berkeley, testing unproven social programs on their taxpayers’ dime. The difference is that Berkeley has a much better tax base to start with, so you don’t see their basic city services (roads, parks, etc.) suffering as much from their activism.

    Oakland can’t afford to pretend we’re Berkeley. Our biggest business (Kaiser) is a non-profit so no tax dollars there. Meanwhile, we have the most people on public assistance, and they don’t pay taxes either.

    We need to conserve our money and stop wasting it on experimental social programs and police/fire departments taking an unfair share of the budget.

  3. Rob

    Also, you’re right to point out the unlikeliness of the 90% number Jordan said. In his own words:

    “Jordan said that two of the four murders were associated with two feuding groups who police believe have been responsible for as many as 90 percent of the murders, robberies and shootings that have taken place in Oakland over the last six to eight months.”

    He himself says only 50% of the murders this weekend were due to this feud. Also, I watch the police blotter and there’s no way any group could get around this large city to commit 90% of the robberies from west to north to east Oakland.

    How could the mayor’s office think they could pull another “90%” (100 blocks) figure like this on the public and not get called on it?

Comments are closed.