Skip to content

Librarians host a story hour to protest library cuts

on May 12, 2011

Cyclists at Ogawa Plaza got more than free pancakes, bike repairs and goodie bags at this year’s East Bay Bike to Work Day. Over a loudspeaker in front of City Hall, a couple of Oakland librarians had something else to share with them. “I went walking, what did you see? I saw a brown horse looking at me,” Amy Martin said as she stood in front of City Hall and read aloud from a giant children’s book.

Nearby, children sat in parents’ laps, clapping and reading along with the book, I Went Walking, and enjoying the impromptu session of story hour. But this story did not end with a happily ever after. Instead, after finishing the book for her young audience, Martin, a children’s librarian at Oakland’s main branch, delivered news of a public library system in peril—telling her listeners that 13 of the city’s 17 library branches may be closed come June. The audience booed and, following Martin’s lead, began to chant “No cuts to libraries!”

A $56 million budget deficit hovering over Oakland means public services like libraries face an uncertain future. In the most extreme budget cut scenario proposed by Mayor Jean Quan, the library system, which currently receives 2 percent of the city’s General Fund, is being threatened with a 60 percent cut—the largest compared to other city budget departments. The cuts would trigger a further loss of funding from the Measure Q parcel tax, creating a potential 85 percent loss in funding for the library system.

A few weeks ago, Mayor Quan announced three budget options for bridging the city’s budget gap. Option A, the most extreme of the three, would reduce the library budget by 85 percent, resulting in little to no funding for programs, class visits, story hours, collections, facilities support, and technology maintenance. This option assumes no new sources of revenue or contributions from employees.

Option B is more of a middle ground scenario, which includes employee concessions, while Option C has the fewest service cuts and layoffs, but requires a special election in June for residents to vote on an $80 parcel tax that would be used to fund libraries and other public services.

Option A, the all-cuts budget proposal, recommends that four libraries remain open: the Main Library, as well as the 81st Avenue, Dimond, and Rockridge branches. For the most part, these are the hub libraries that are in the busiest, and wealthiest, neighborhoods of Oakland.

“What you have left out is West Oakland and the vast majority of East Oakland,” said Martin, speaking as an Oakland resident and not a library spokeperson. “It’s nightmarish to us in the library. … We’ve worked so hard to provide materials for people who are in the poorest communities.”

For example, the Caesar Chavez branch would be one of the libraries slated to close. The entirely Spanish-language branch is in the middle of the Fruitvale neighborhood and currently offers ESL classes and other services that specifically serve people with language barriers.

Even with the four branches that would remain with Option A, Martin said there’d be a major lack of services. In the all-cuts budget proposal, the main library would be budgeted to have four full-time staff working in a three-story building. Martin said this means they would barely be able to open the front door, let alone continue providing classes and programs for patrons.

The budget for repairing computers and purchasing new materials like books and DVDs would also be eliminated. “There wouldn’t be anything left,” Martin said. “We’d have open doors with broken computers.”

The library currently receives its funding primarily from two sources: the City of Oakland’s General Fund and Measure Q, a dedicated $14 million library parcel tax passed by voters in 2004.  Under Measure Q, the city may collect the parcel tax only if it authorizes General Fund support of at least $9 million per year—that means the city can no longer collect the parcel tax money if library funding falls below the required threshold.

The city council could propose that voters amend Measure Q, removing the matching funds requirement from the city so that that the library can continue to collect those funds. But doing so would require a special election.

Martin said the library needs a more dedicated funding source from the city. “It can feel like the hard work you put in is not being recognized by city council,” Martin said, “and that they’re not understanding what we’re trying to do, which is raise good citizens for Oakland.”

At this morning’s story hour, Martin and the other librarians encouraged onlookers to show support for libraries by attending the City Council Budget Hearing at City Hall Council Chambers tonight at 5:30 pm.

For more information about which library branches and services are at risk for closure, visit


  1. pati on May 12, 2011 at 3:10 pm

  2. Annabelle on May 12, 2011 at 5:18 pm

    Thanks for the support.

    I work at the Chavez Branch and just wanted to make a few corrections.

    In addition to materials in Spanish, our collection has English language items as well. It’s pretty much half and half.

    Unfortunately we no longer have ESL classes, BUT we do offer the following services in Spanish AND English:

    -Preschool Storytime
    -Computer Classes
    -Lawyer in the Library

    For more information you can see our web page:

    Thanks again.

  3. alex on May 12, 2011 at 11:18 pm

    This young children’s librarian is right.on the axis of west to east there would be three libraries available to the public according to scenario A: the main library,Dimond and the newly built 81st.the children would be the sacrificial lambs.

  4. DC on May 17, 2011 at 9:10 am

    The city is broke. I’d be curious to see how much of an increase in library usage there’s been since the passage of the huge library funding tax about ten years ago?

    But then again in Oakland, if they actually did the math and noticed 20% less people were using the library, instead of cutting 20%, they’d move to sustain the same level of service. I believe this may be attributed to the little known fact that the brain actually suffers from a state of reduced function as an elected official.

  5. […] Cyclists in downtown Oakland, California, got more than free pancakes and bike repairs May 12 at East Bay Bike to Work Day. Over a loudspeaker, two Oakland librarians had something else to share with them. “I went walking, what did you see? I saw a brown horse looking at me,” Amy Martin (right) said as she stood in front of City Hall and read aloud from Sue Williams’s I Went Walking. Martin, children’s librarian at Oakland’s main branch, also told her listeners that 13 of the city’s 17 library branches may be closed come June. Save Oakland Libraries has a Facebook page. Another group is planning a May 21 Zombie Crawl. Read more… […]

  6. […] libraries, which branches could be shut down, and about a previous guerilla storytime protest by clicking here for Nicole Jones’ previous story. You can also listen to other audio stories at Oakland North […]

  7. […] Option A, ” said library director Carmen Martinez, who was showing the crowd a city map with only four of its current 17 libraries marked as open. The “all cuts” budget option, or Option A, is one of the three budget scenarios proposed by […]

Oakland North welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Oakland North assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.

Photo by Basil D Soufi
Oakland North

Oakland North is an online news service produced by students at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and covering Oakland, California. Our goals are to improve local coverage, innovate with digital media, and listen to you–about the issues that concern you and the reporting you’d like to see in your community. Please send news tips to:

Latest Posts

Scroll To Top