Skip to content

Mayor Quan responds to residents filing for her recall

on November 2, 2011

Oakland Mayor Jean Quan released an official statement Monday about the efforts of Oakland residents to recall her, saying that the city did not need a “divisive and expensive” recall election and listing her accomplishments during her 294-day tenure as mayor.

“Oaklanders know me as a woman of action, fighting hard and delivering results,” she wrote.

Last week a group of 71 Oakland residents filed a petition to recall Quan, writing that she had “willfully ignored the city’s most pressing issue: public safety.” The registrar of voters certified 56 of the signatures as those of registered voters in Oakland, allowing the petitioners to continue to the next step in the recall process. This involves submitting a legal notice of the petition to the city clerk’s office within 10 days. The notice would give the petitioners another 160 days to collect about 19,800 signatures on the petition, or approximately 10 percent of registered Oakland voters.

In her statement, Quan addressed the petitioners’ assertions that she had not been able to address crime. She wrote that during her tenure, she had negotiated pension reforms to rehire 36 police officers; secured a federal grant for 25 more officers; developed a crime reduction plan focused  on the 100 blocks of Oakland where the most crime occurs; and held a safety summit and multiple town hall meetings with over 1,000 participants.

Regarding the petitioners’ allegations that she has not done enough for port redevelopment, she said she had both led regional and international meetings to help the port’s operations, and had also led China trade missions. She wrote that she had secured an agreement on a $400 million development to bring federal and state grants to the port and create 3,000 jobs.

Gene Hazzard, who collected the original 71 signatures supporting Quan’s recall, said the mayor’s assertion that the recall campaign would be expensive was misleading. “Let it be clear that these are in no way expenses borne by the taxpayer,” he said. “The opponent will have to raise the money. This is not at the city’s expense.”

Hazzard said  a major concern for him and other petitioners is the fact that the city’s charter does not address what would happen if the recall should be successful.

The charter does state that the office of the mayor will be filled by the vice-mayor if a vacancy is declared. If less than a year remains in the mayor’s term, and the vice-mayor declines the position, the city council must determine the next mayor through a majority vote of its members. If more than a year of the recalled mayor’s term is left, a special new mayoral election must be within 120 days.

But the charter does not explicitly define “vacancy,” and whether the recalling of a mayor constitutes one, and hence defers to state law in the case of a recall. State law requires that the governing body issue an order  that an election be held within 14 days of verifying the signatures on the recall petition. The election itself must be held within 88 to 125 days after the issuance of the order, and can be consolidated with any scheduled regular or special elections.

“Based on what happened with [former California Governor Gray Davis], there could simultaneously be a vote for the mayor’s office,” said Hazzard, referring to the 2003 recall election, during which Davis was replaced by Arnold Schwarzenegger. “But the state could say, ‘Because you’re a charter city, do what you want.’”

The recall petitioners must collect all their signatures by April 2012, 160 days after filing the notice of intent. “In 20 years of serving Oakland, my only agenda has been to work hard for our diverse city,” wrote Quan, addressing her constituents. “I consider it a sacred trust.”


  1. Charles Pine on November 2, 2011 at 3:22 pm

    Whether you love Occupy Oakland, are appalled by it, or want to influence its next transformation, if you are an Oakland resident, you realize that “mayor Quan” is a contradiction in terms.

    Quan is simply incapable of the leadership that the office requires. A long history prior to the Occupy debacle revealed this fact – ebonics, school district bankruptcy, Measure Y, and this year’s “balancing” the City budget with an accounting trick, driving out popular chief Anthony Batts as well as the city attorney, even her denial of the fire danger at her residence.

    For more on the recall campaign and for a link to get email notification when petition-signing begins, see

  2. Pocho on November 3, 2011 at 11:22 am

    OF COURSE………….
    anyone supporting the recall of this ‘activistmayor’ is a RACIST!
    Tea Partyer, Republican, Literer, Pet Kicker,
    Homophobe or Christian.

  3. Published Works « Syeda Amna Hassan on June 10, 2012 at 9:05 pm

    […] Mayor Quan responds to residents filing for her recall […]

  4. […] But the city’s use of force was drawing criticism, too. The city government and the Oakland Police Department came under national scrutiny as a result of the crowd control tactics used against protesters.  “The whole way Occupy Oakland was bungled by the mayor, at the outset, cost the city millions of dollars,” recall Frank Castro, who was involved in one of the unsuccessful subsequent efforts to recall Mayor Jean Quan. […]

Oakland North welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Oakland North assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.

Photo by Basil D Soufi
Oakland North

Oakland North is an online news service produced by students at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and covering Oakland, California. Our goals are to improve local coverage, innovate with digital media, and listen to you–about the issues that concern you and the reporting you’d like to see in your community. Please send news tips to:

Latest Posts

Scroll To Top