Skip to content

Alex Lujano browses a book at the "People's Library" in the Fruitvale district.

Neighbors organize an outdoor library in the Fruitvale

on August 30, 2012

Over the past two weeks an impromptu library has sprung up on the location of the former Latin American Library in the Fruitvale district. A group of nearly fifteen people, including a few Occupy Oakland protesters and several community members, have been loaning out books, constructing planters for gardening and holding community meetings.

The library was closed after the Loma Prieta earthquake in 1989, although the structure was later used as a school called the Emiliano Zapata Academy. But for the past ten years the property remained abandoned and is considered unsafe. Currently, the nearest open public library is almost a mile away.

Books wait to be organized and shelved at the "People's Library".

Books wait to be organized and shelved at the “People’s Library.”

In the early morning hours of August 13, a contingent of Occupy Oakland members took over the library building, which is located at E. 15th Street and Miller Avenue. Volunteers began cleaning up the building and grounds as others filled shelves with books. The group also renamed the building, calling it “The Victor Martinez People’s Library” after the late Latino poet.

“Our goal was to put the books in, get the banner up, to propagate in people’s minds that this was something that they could do,” said Jaime Omar Yassin, a community activist and Occupy member who lives in the neighborhood. “They could just take this building over if it’s not being used correctly.”

According to Yassin, prior to the group’s arrival, the property was occupied primarily by sex workers and drug addicts. While cleaning the building, they found old mattresses along with “a sharps bin full of needles,” he said.

But hours after the group occupied the building, police officers arrived and asked them to vacate the premises, saying the building needed seismic retrofitting and was not safe for use, according to Yassin. The group complied and the front door was then boarded up by city workers, he said.

The protesters then set up shop on the sidewalk on Miller Avenue in front of the property. A week later they moved their library onto the back lawn.

On Tuesday morning, Yassin casually stepped through a hole in the chain-link fence surrounding the old library building and walked onto the grounds, just as he had done throughout the past week. Scores of books, many of which came from the library that had been set up in downtown Oakland during last fall’s Occupy protests, sat on shelves lined up against the abandoned building. Some chairs and a small table sat under a tree and, across the yard, a series of planter boxes where rows of collard greens, lettuce and chives were sprouting.

The group has also been receiving book donations by mail. At one point during the day a UPS package arrived containing three children’s books—one written in Vietnamese and the other two in Spanish. Some supporters also sent postcards. One was postmarked Baton Rouge, Louisiana, and encouraged participants to “Keep up the great work!”

Hand drawn poster hang on the fence outside of the library building.

Hand-drawn posters hang on the fence outside of the library building.

Over the next hour, a few people from the neighborhood wandered in to browse books and say hello. Liliana Macedonio, 26, who lives less than a block away, brought her three children to play as she sold popsicles on E. 15th Street.  “We want this to be open,” she said, referring to the outdoor library. Otherwise, she said, “it’s very far to go get a book for our children.”

Alex Lujano, 50, lives just down the street and has been an active member of the library project since its inception. He said he was not involved in community activism prior to the library occupation, but he supports this project because he believes his neighborhood needs a safe place for kids to play. Children often come by to read books and play games, such as a board game called “Anti-Monopoly.”

Lujano said he plans to appeal to the city council to reopen the building and allow them to use it, not only as a library, but also for day care services and English language classes. In the meantime he plans to support this impromptu library. “I believe it’s a great opportunity for those of us who live in the neighborhood,” Lujano said.

But not everyone supports the group’s endeavors. Pastor Lambert Simmons leads the Agnes Memorial Church of God in Christ, located across the street from the property. A pastor there since 1984, Simmons said he was concerned about the example that the group is setting for young people in the area, because they entered the property illegally and are using it without permission.

“I believe everything needs to be done decently and in order,” he said. “We don’t need any more law-breaking. That’s a bad example to the kids in the neighborhood. You just don’t be trespassing on people’s property.”

When asked why police evicted the protesters from the building earlier in the week, District 5 councilmember Ignacio De La Fuente said by telephone Wednesday afternoon, “It’s a public facility that we are responsible for. Even if we agree with the message, we cannot allow that to happen.”

De La Fuente said a compromise allowing the group to use the outdoor grounds as a community space could “possibly” be worked out if they apply for a permit.

On Tuesday afternoon, at around 1:00 pm, three Oakland police officers accompanied city workers, who closed the hole Yassin had so effortlessly used to enter the premises just a few hours before. An officer assured Yassin that their “goal [was] to not destroy the garden” and that they were “not trying to do anything with the books.”

The protesters voluntarily left the library grounds when they saw the officers walking up. They decided to bring the library onto the sidewalk on E. 15th Street between two garden planters they had built days earlier.

Later that night, approximately fifteen neighbors gathered on the street nearby to decide next steps. They plan to hold meetings every Tuesday at 5:30 pm to brainstorm new ideas for the project.

Meanwhile, Occupy Seattle has followed Fruitvale’s example and began their own “People’s Library” in front of their main library—which has been closed temporarily due to budget cuts—though Yassin said there is minimal communication between the two groups.

“We were excited about the fact that we inspired them to do it,” he said.


  1. AlanKurtz on August 30, 2012 at 5:43 pm

    There’s no evidence Occupy Oakland is behind the People’s Library. You report that “a contingent of Occupy Oakland members took over the library building” on August 13 and that “a few Occupy Oakland protesters” have been involved in ongoing activities.

    However, Occupy Oakland did not approve the takeover through a resolution by the General Assembly or via any of its autonomous committees. Nor has Occupy Oakland retroactively endorsed this action, for which one member—Jaime Omar Yassin—is solely responsible.

    You quote Mr. Yassin as stating that one of his goals is “to propagate in people’s minds that this was something that they could do. They could just take this building over if it’s not being used correctly.”

    That, in a nutshell, is the criminal ethos of anarchists who believe they are entitled to “just take” municipal property “if it’s not being used correctly.”

    Pastor Simmons is correct in calling this “a bad example to the kids in the neighborhood.” As he notes, “We don’t need any more law-breaking.”

    • Gulo gulo on September 1, 2012 at 12:40 pm

      Please. The evidence that Occupy Oakland is involved is all over this library action – many occupy participants are also involved here. That it did or didn’t receive official sanction from the GA is unimportant. Occupy is a verb. What you say seems almost desperately bureaucratic.
      Re: the accusations of criminality, well, yes, rules on the books have been broken. And rightly so. It is axiomatic that social movements challenging the state lack the authority of the rule of law; instead our power derives from collective action and popular support. The library has demonstrated both in spades, reactionary pastors notwithstanding.

  2. jaime omar yassin on September 4, 2012 at 1:12 am

    Alan: The bottomliners for occupying the library were almost all Occupy Oakland members. Like many actions, it was an autonomous one, however. Occupy Oakland has always had a fairly easy to understand system of action; large actions that require lots of money and organizing are generally brought through the general assembly because of the logistical needs required and the large activist community they can access. Smaller actions that don’t require much in funds or resources, and that won’t require bringing out hundreds or thousands of folks, can be done autonomously. There were about seven of us that first morning. And that grew fairly quickly. Many of the people that answered the social media call that we subsequently put out, were in fact, people who’ve been associated with Occupy Oakland. But in the subsequent hours, members of the surrounding neighborhood also became part of the action. They continued to support and be active in it in all of its permutations since; some of these folks have lived in the community for their entire lives others have lived there for over a decade. Is this an Occupy Oakland action? Yes, from the perspective that this kind of action has been resurrected and made viable in the past year or so, and would not have likely happened without the kinds of informal networks that OO brought together since October in terms of issue specific committees that together gave the collective its character. No, from the perspective that it has moved from being an activist sponsored occupation, to a neighborhood driven series of assemblies about taking control of this empty space that has served as a blighted negative force in the community for over a decade.

    During that decade, many have tried to use the “official channels” that the pastor urges us to access. The outcome is predictable and obvious; nothing changed. Why? Because the neighborhood is full of poor and politically powerless people who are off the district’s “improvement zone” radar. As for “criminal” activity, the guiding lights of the civil rights movement were criminals. They did hard-time, in fact, for breaking laws that they deemed unjust. Some of these folks were, in fact, men of god, who believed that moral and ethical power emerged from love of humanity, not ephemeral codices that change according to the capricious prejudices of any given era. If there is a law that prevents people from taking a field of syringes and broken glass that children already access in a completely unstructured way via a decrepit chainlink fence built before the age of the personal computer and making it into a community garden and learning center for their kids, then its a law that needs to be treated as blind, unjust and counterproductive.

    Ironically, almost all of the people quoted in this piece who stand by the law in question preventing people from improving the area themselves in absence of civic efforts, live nowhere near this area–especially the police.

  3. Pixie Dust For Your Friday « Caitlin Jacobs on September 28, 2012 at 8:08 am

    […] you ever heard of an outdoor library? Do you have one near you? There’s not much I can think of that would be cooler than that. […]

  4. 9000mah行動電源 on June 22, 2013 at 12:22 pm

    fairly practical things, general I think this is worthy of a bookmark, thanks

Oakland North welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Oakland North assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.

Photo by Basil D Soufi
Oakland North

Oakland North is an online news service produced by students at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and covering Oakland, California. Our goals are to improve local coverage, innovate with digital media, and listen to you–about the issues that concern you and the reporting you’d like to see in your community. Please send news tips to:

Latest Posts

Scroll To Top