Skip to content

Anthony Toribio

Few answers about Jordan’s medical retirement at press conference

on May 9, 2013

City and police officials expressed their surprise at Oakland Police Chief Howard Jordan’s abrupt resignation, but had few details about what prompted the Wednesday morning announcement.

At a standing-room-only press conference Wednesday afternoon at OPD headquarters, police spokesperson Johnna Watson and City Administrator Deanna Santana were asked repeatedly whether Thomas Frazier, the department’s compliance director, had recommended Jordan’s removal. They would not directly respond to the questions. Frazier released a report last week that criticized the department’s command structure and investigations of alleged police misconduct. In a notice posted on the city’s website, Jordan said he was seeking retirement for medical reasons.

“I cannot share any medical information other than he is on medical leave and he is taking steps toward a medical retirement,” Santana said.

She said Frazier and federal monitor Robert Warshaw, who tracks the department’s progress on the decade-old Negotiated Settlement Agreement from the 2000 “Riders” police misconduct lawsuit, have been notified of Jordan’s announcement.

Jordan was not at the press conference. City officials are looking to open a nationwide search as soon as possible to find a replacement, Santana said.

In a letter to OPD officers and in a statement on the city’s website, Jordan said the decision was “difficult, but necessary.” Assistant Chief Anthony Toribio will become the department’s acting chief and will handle the department’s day-to-operations.

“I understand the suddenness of this change may cause uncertainty within and outside the department,” Toribio said at the press conference. “By the very manner and structure of our organization, Chief Jordan’s departure caused no uncertainty in the department’s mission or progress. I carry the same commitment to the work now underway.”

The abrupt resignation came moments before a scheduled noontime news conference with Jordan and former New York City and Los Angeles Police Commissioner Bill Bratton. That press conference was quickly canceled and rescheduled for Thursday morning. Bratton was set to present a crime reduction plan that was a part of a $250,000 contract that brought in a six-member consultant panel in late January.

“This not the press conference I thought we were going to have today,” Mayor Jean Quan said. She reminisced about the first time she met Jordan, when he was a young lieutenant working to professionalize the Oakland public schools’ police force years ago.

“What I learned then, which I have been happy to see over the years, is that this is a man who can talk to young people, who would walk the walk,” she said. “I am saddened to hear the news. I trust he is doing what’s best for himself and his family.”

Quan said she thinks the city will still have hiring authority for the next chief, but that the compliance director and federal monitor will probably want a say in the hiring process.

Multiple Oakland city officials attended the press conference, including District 5 Councilman Noel Gallo, District 7 Councilman Larry Reid, District 1 Councilman Dan Kalb and Council President Pat Kernighan.

“I really have a lot of admiration for [Jordan],” Kernighan said afterward. “He has stepped up, challenge after challenge. We’re going to miss him.”

Rashidah Grinage, director of PUEBLO, a community group that advocates for low-income Oakland residents, said despite his initial enthusiasm, Jordan had dragged his feet on several proposals, including one for business cards for OPD officers that could be given to community members.

“I certainly have been extremely frustrated with him recently,” she said in a phone interview. “I don’t even know if the person who succeeds him will be as enthusiastic about these proposals, in theory. Without knowing who his replacement will be, it’s hard to know whether this will be a step forward or not.”

You can read more about Jordan’s tenure as Oakland Police Chief here.

Update: May 10, 2013: Less than one day after announcing that Toribio would head the department, city officials announced that the Interim Chief of Police would instead be Sean Whent, who previously served as the deputy chief of the department’s Bureau of Risk Management, an office that oversees the Internal Affairs Division, among others. According to the city release, “Toribio has made a personal decision to step down to the position of Captain of Police. He fully supports the new leadership and will continue to contribute to the Department’s ongoing effort to reduce crime and meet full compliance with the Negotiated Settlement Agreement.”


  1. Len Raphael on May 12, 2013 at 9:57 pm

    As newbies to Oakland you might not know it, but this has been the most chaotic week in the past chaotic decade of OPD and City Hall.

    Might even have been the lowest point of OPD in it’s history.

    And you have nothing more to say than repeating the press release and quoting one community activist?

    You are training to be journalists, not public relations flacks, right?

    ON, you can do much better.

  2. Len Raphael on May 12, 2013 at 10:10 pm

    The latest mess at OPD is qualitatively different from other continuing problems at OPD and City Hall.

    Best an outsider like myself can figure out, Mayor Quan’s administrator, Ms Santana and Mayor Quan did not fully grasp the reality that OPD is in Federal receivership in every sense but formal name.

    (btw, under Oakland’s system, Ms Santana has the day to day decision making power, not Quan. The Mayor can fire her but not tell her what to do. So it’s more important what Santana does than what Quan says.)

    Chief Jordan understood the Federal reality much better than Santana or Quan and apparently parachuted out on medical retirement before the Federal overseer/receiver, Frazier, replaced him with “interim chief” Sean Whent. If Chief Jordan were healthy, he would have have been demoted to a much lower paying position and could not have retired for another 3 or 4 years at a much lower pension than he would get as Chief on medical retirement. We’re talking 50 to 75k/year lower retirement.

    Short of convincing our City Council members to successfully appeal to higher Federal Court to remove Judge Henderson (we’d lose that appeal), residents are now more powerless than usual to influence the public security decisions made downtown.

    Frazier and his puppet Whent will fire a bunch of brass and a bunch of street cops, who probably needed to go anyway. But the witch hunt process will demoralize a whole bunch of good cops who will look for other cities to transfer to.

    Street cops will pay even more attention to office politics than to solving crimes for the next couple of years. Eventually, Frazier will declare compliance and depart, leaving a department that at least treats its residents with more respect even if can’t police it’s way out of a bag.

    That’s when residents have to make sure City Hall manages OPD hecka better than it did during the past three decades leading up to this current morass and properly funds and supports OPD. Giving OPD a bunch more money now is just throwing good money after bad.

Oakland North welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Oakland North assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.

Photo by Basil D Soufi
Oakland North

Oakland North is an online news service produced by students at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and covering Oakland, California. Our goals are to improve local coverage, innovate with digital media, and listen to you–about the issues that concern you and the reporting you’d like to see in your community. Please send news tips to:

Latest Posts

Scroll To Top