Oakland teachers protest amidst fraught contract negotiations
on October 2, 2018
Last week, Oakland teachers across the district held demonstrations at their schools to demand a new contract. Outside of Oakland International High School in Temescal, a group of about 20 teachers and students held signs that read “Support Oakland Teachers” and “End the teacher crisis.” Cars passing by honked to show their support.
Susan Keen, a history teacher at the school, led a chant. “When education is under attack, what do we do?” yelled Keen.
“Stand up, fight back!” the group chanted in response.
The teachers handed out fliers and asked people walking if they had a moment to support Oakland teachers. A new chant broke out: “Get up, get down, Oakland is a union town!”
Oakland public school teachers have been working without a contract since July, 2017. The Oakland Unified School District (OUSD) and the Oakland Education Association (OEA), the teachers’ union, have been in negotiations since January of that year. Two central issues have kept the sides from reaching an agreement over the last 20 months: teacher compensation and class sizes.
The union has sought to phase in a class size reduction of one student per class per year over the next two years. At schools with high percentage of students who are either English learners, foster youth or receive free or reduced lunch (which indicates that they come from a low-income houseshold), the union is asking for a reduction of two students per class per year. District officials have proposed a reduction of one student per year for only physical education and fine arts classes.
The union also sought a 3 percent salary raise for teachers plus other school staff, such as nurses, counselors, and librarians, for the 2017-18 school year; a 4 percent raise in 2018-19 (with 1 percent coming from Measure G1 funding); and a 5 percent raise in 2019-20. Measure G1 was a parcel tax to fund salary increases for teachers, as well as art and music enrichment programs for Oakland middle school students. It passed with 82.24 percent of the vote in 2016.
The OUSD’s offer was no raise in 2017-18, a half-percent raise with 1.5 percent bonus from Measure G1 and extra hours worked in 2018-19, and a half-percent raise with a 1.5 percent bonus from Measure G1 and extra hours worked in 2019-20.
“We’re frustrated. We’re at a breaking point. And we’re willing to fight back,” said Keen, who is a union site representative for her school.
The negotiations began with a few agreements in early 2017. Both sides were able to agree on the school calendars for the next several school years, along with a plan to implement affirmative action policies in the district’s hiring process. But the two sides have been unable to find common ground on issues that would have financial effects on the district.
The district’s precarious financial position has hung over the negotiations throughout the process. In January, 2017, the OUSD was in the midst of a leadership change following the abrupt resignation of former Superintendent Antwan Wilson in late 2016. Wilson left the OUSD with a budget deficit of about $30 million, largely due to overspending on administrators and outside consultants. Superintendent Kyla Johnson-Trammel was named Wilson’s successor in May, 2017.
Facing a potential state takeover of the district, district staff and the school board approved about $22.6 million in cuts for the 2017-18 school year. That December, the board approved another $9 million in midyear budget cuts, despite protests from the public.
Negotiations between the teachers’ union and the district failed to make significant progress through 2017 and up until May, 2018. Given the district’s budget woes, a raise in teacher salaries was the primary sticking point.
Angela Badami-Knight, a former Oakland special education teacher and the manager of educator community at GO Public Schools Oakland (GO), a non-profit that advocates for improved fiscal practices in the district and collaboration between public and charter schools, has been following the negotiations closely. “It seems there’s a disagreement about whether or not the district is financially able to offer the things that the OEA wants, or even come close to that,” she said.
Kate Sbani, a kindergarten teacher at Hoover Elementary School, who was protesting in front of her school last week, said she recognizes that the district faces serious budget challenges, but wants to see district officials prioritize student learning when deciding where budget cuts should come from. To her, that means prioritizing “teachers having quality of life and feeling that their job is respected and professional.”
“Teachers can’t afford to live in Oakland. It’s a very emotional, personal subject. If I didn’t have my partner’s salary, I couldn’t afford to rent in Oakland,” Sbani said.
Rent prices in Oakland have grown by over 50 percent since 2012, with the median rent cost going from $1,952 to $2,950, according to a study by Trulia, a company that aggregates housing market information. The median sales price for a house in Oakland is up to $750,000 as of April, 2018, according to Trulia. While teacher salaries have also grown during that time frame, Sbani said it’s not enough, particularly for teachers who want to buy a house. “There’s a lot of conversation among a lot of teachers that I know of moving outside of Oakland and buying a house in Crockett or Vallejo or El Sobrante or other places that are more affordable,” she said.
According to California Department of Education’s J-90 report on salaries in 2016-17, Oakland teachers get paid less than their peers in nearby districts in Alameda County. The starting teacher salary in Oakland was $46,411, which ranks in the lower half compared to other districts in the county. In nearby Hayward, a new teacher started with a salary of $61,672.
For experienced teachers, who have 10 years of experience and an additional 60 college credits, the salary was $63,904, which is the lowest in the county. At Berkeley Unified, a teacher with equivalent experiences made $72,595 a year. The highest salary for Oakland teachers was $83,437, which is second to last in Alameda County. In San Leandro, the highest salary was $109,742.
Oakland teachers do receive one of the best healthcare benefits packages—about a $13,500 contribution from the district—compared to teachers in nearby districts, who sometimes don’t receive any benefits. Despite that, some find it hard to ignore the long-term effects of the pay gap between Oakland and nearby districts.
Matthew Hayes, a seventh grade history and physical education teacher at Life Academy, who also serves as the union site representative there, said the pay gap weighs on him, particularly since his wife is pregnant with their first child. “I could make, hypothetically, $20,000 more by going to a neighboring district. When you’re thinking of the cost of sending a student to college,” he said, “if you get paid $20,000 more a year over a child’s lifetime, that’s almost $400,000, right? And it’s just hard to justify staying here when you have to think about your own family.”
Hayes’ wife works as public school teacher in Albany. She makes about $7,000 more a year than him, and Albany also offers better resources and working conditions, according to Hayes.
The other issue keeping the union and the district apart in negotiations is the teachers’ request for a reduction in class sizes. According to Sbani, who just received a new student in her class about a month into the school year, class sizes affect teachers’ ability to do their jobs well. “I can’t give them the attention they need. If I have so many kids, it’s really difficult to provide the best instruction,” she said, “especially when there’s a growing number of kids that have special needs.”
In May, after 18 months of negotiations, the union declared an impasse with the Public Employee Relations Board (PERB), the agency that administers collective bargaining agreements for employees of California’s public institutions. An impasse is invoked when the two parties are deadlocked. At that point, PERB assigned a mediator to the negotiations. Mediation sessions began on August 31.
Last week’s demonstrations were planned to take place one day ahead of the most recent mediation session on September 26. Sbani and a group of about 10 teachers were out in front of Hoover Elementary, holding signs and passing out fliers with information about the negotiations to parents who were dropping off their kids.
John Sasaki, OUSD communications director, declined to comment on the most recent mediation session.
District officials’ most recent public statement on mediation was released on September 12. “The mediator assigned by PERB concluded the [September 10] session by stating ‘We’ve made significant progress in sharing information and running through various conceptual agreements on major topics,’” the press release stated.
Keith Brown, the president of OEA, said in a phone interview that in the coming mediation sessions the union is “hoping to see significant movement from the district, and for the district to listen to our community and listen to parents and students and really make some serious steps to ending the teacher retention crisis in Oakland.”
Brown considers the central issues of the negotiations—teacher pay and working conditions—as the primary factors causing Oakland’s high rate of teacher turnover. “It’s very difficult to maintain being a teacher when you cannot afford basic necessities, and not only basic necessities for yourself and your living conditions, but teachers are coming out of pocket for basic supplies like pens or pencils,” he said.
Hayes said he spends upwards of $1,000 a year on supplies for his classroom, including healthy snacks for students, markers, binders and books for students to read for fun. As a physical education coach, he also needs to maintain his cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) certification, and the district doesn’t pay for it. He believes that this is part of a larger, national issue with how people view teachers. “We tend to just think of them as these heroes where we want to give them teacher appreciation weeks, or we want to give discounts at Target for teachers to buy school supplies,” Hayes said. “But when push comes to shove, no one wants to pay us like professionals.”
Keen said that based on surveys she gave to teachers at Oakland International High School, 69 percent plan on leaving the district in the next five years. “All I’m doing is talking about the teacher crisis. To my friends, to my family, everyone,” Keen said.
Badami-Knight from GO is hopeful that mediation can produce some agreements. She said that the district has a clearer picture of its financial state now than it’s had at any point during negotiations so far, and is “moving towards best practices like making sure that you have ongoing funds to pay for ongoing expenses.”
Recently, some signs of financial improvement were on display. At a school board meeting on September 12, district staff revealed that they ended the 2017-18 school year with a budget surplus of $29 million.
The district also received additional state aid through AB 1840, which will provide a one-time package of $20 million to cover its deficit, but only if the district demonstrates better financial practices. Those practices include making significant budget cuts to the 2019-20 school year. Before the state aid package was announced, district staff and the school board were planning on making roughly $30 million in cuts to the 2019-20 budget. While the state aid may reduce the amount, but cuts are still expected—and that’s before accounting for a potential salary raise for teachers.
Badami-Knight said a balance is required: “Teachers absolutely deserve it, they are not paid enough, and also, whatever agreement comes out needs to be, needs to continue the district on the path to financial stability.”
The next two mediation sessions will be held on October 10 and October 23. If the two sides are unable to reach an agreement, the negotiations will move to a fact-finding phase. During fact finding, both sides present their best arguments to a neutral person appointed by PERB. The appointee then weighs the arguments and releases a recommendation for settlement to the public. The recommendation is non-binding, so the two sides continue bargaining based on the recommendation.
If an agreement still can’t be reached, a teachers’ strike is possible. “We do not want to strike, because we’re in this profession for our students, because students are the center of everything we do. But if we’re forced to take that action, we will,” Brown said. “But it will be for our students, because our students deserve nothing less than a quality education.”
Keen said that when she talks to people in Oakland about the negotiations, they are almost always supportive of teachers. But she believes many don’t quite understand just how dire the situation has become. “Oakland doesn’t realize how close its own backyard is to striking,” Keen said over the blaring of car horns.
A few minutes later, she started up the chant again: “When education is under attack, what do we do?”
“Stand up, fight back!” the teachers responded in unison.
Oakland North is an online news service produced by students at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and covering Oakland, California. Our goals are to improve local coverage, innovate with digital media, and listen to you–about the issues that concern you and the reporting you’d like to see in your community. Please send news tips to: firstname.lastname@example.org.