Skip to content

At the last moment, Oakland City Council votes in new budget

on July 1, 2011

Three hours ahead of the new fiscal year, Oakland’s city council finally voted in a budget. The council, by a narrow vote, approved the biennial budget resolution during a special council meeting on Thursday evening.

The council—which diverged over the rehiring of laid-off police officers and other government reorganization issues—split into two groups as members voted 4-4 on a budget proposal advanced by Council President Larry Reid (District 7), Vice Mayor Desley Brooks (District 6), Councilmember Jane Brunner (District 1) and Ignacio De La Fuente (District 5). The tie was broken by Mayor Jean Quan, who  voted in favor of the proposal.

The approved budget will maintain the current public library services, keep all fire stations open and continue to fund cultural arts grants. However, it will only hire back 22 laid-off police officers, as called for in Quan’s initial proposal. An alternative proposal, put forward by councilmembers Libby Schaaf (District 4), Rebecca Kaplan (At-large), Nancy Nadel (District 1) and Patricia Kernighan (District 3), had called for hiring back an additional 18 officers. Schaaf said that as Oakland continues to lose its police officers at an increasing rate, it’s very cost-effective to hire back officers who have already been trained to work in the city.

However, Brooks, on behalf of her group, said adding more officers to the city’s payroll is not a fiscally sustainable decision. De La Fuente added that it would not be fair when the other city employee unions are making great sacrifices—including concessions on salary reductions and pension contributions—to help close the city’s budget gap, while the police officers’ union is asking for a cost-of-living salary increase in 2014 and 2015.

As a compromise, Kaplan brought up the idea of setting up a public safety reserve fund, which can be utilized to hire police officers once the city’s police staffing level is too low. The other group of councilmembers, who prefer to put the money (roughly $3 million a year) into the general reserve fund, did not adopt the suggestion.

Councilmembers also debated cuts to the city’s Public Ethics Office and the elimination of Oaklanders Assistance Center (an office which helps resident navigate through city services and policies), as well as whether to lay off four tax enforcement officers. After two hours of argument, the council had to break briefly for the two factions to have caucus meetings to figure out which concessions each group could accept. During the recess, the Reid group decided to add back the funding for the Chabot Science Center and maintain the National Night Out program, which Quan told a number of reporters are the major reasons for her decision to favor the Reid group’s budget during the tie-breaking vote.

While eliminating the part-time assistant to the Public Ethics Director and Oaklanders Assistance Center, the newly adopted budget will lead to the installation of 369 parking meters, which will feed the city with more than $1 million a year.

The budget can be amended as the city fumbles through the new fiscal year, Quan told the press after casting her vote. “But we really need a budget now, or the city’s credit is going to be hurt,” she said.


  1. […] the Oakland Tribune has an article detailing the City Council meeting. Oakland North also has a post up about was cut and what was kept in order to balance the […]

  2. Leonard Raphael on July 3, 2011 at 12:56 am

    To read this is to think the CC achieved something other than papering over massive structural fiscal problems for another few months. Neither faction dealt with the structural problems. Neither faction figured out a way to reduce the cost of city government employees of all depts so that we the residents could get more service at lower cost, instead of less service at essentially the same costs that are the highest in the country for all muni employees, not just cops and firefighters.

    Just an footnote insult to the residents was elimination of the Assistance Center which actually had competent people helping residents but kept Quan’s warm and cozy National Night out BBQ program.

    Still what were our city mothers and fathers thinking when they agreed to the cops OPOA demand to promise not to support repeal of the Charters’ binding arbitration guarantee?

    The OPOA asked for that because it is the main protection they have against big pay cuts we need from all city employees and non profit programming so we can afford more employees not fewer but highly paid ones.

    The other employee unions didn’t bother to ask for a similar assurance on repealing the anti-outsourcing charter clause, because they knew the Council was too timid to even touch that.

    The council sold our democratic control of our government for a measily 9% pension contribution by the cops. Sad how low a price they put on selling out the residents.

    -len raphael, temescal

  3. […] until last week, when the city council voted in a new budget that preserved library services, Ty Yurgelevic, the Temescal Tool Lending Library manager, wasn’t […]

Oakland North welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Oakland North assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.

Photo by Basil D Soufi
Oakland North

Oakland North is an online news service produced by students at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and covering Oakland, California. Our goals are to improve local coverage, innovate with digital media, and listen to you–about the issues that concern you and the reporting you’d like to see in your community. Please send news tips to:

Latest Posts

Scroll To Top