Community members tell OUSD school board to reinstate free supper program
on September 28, 2018
On Wednesday night, more than 50 students, parents and community organizers demanded that Oakland school board members restore the district’s free supper program. The program, which served hot meals to more than 3,000 students, was eliminated in June because of budget cuts.
“I should not have to stand up here and tell you why my peers and I deserve to eat, but here I am telling adults whose very job it is to serve children that taking meals away from them is wrong,” Liliana Pacheco, a senior at Oakland High School, told the board.
Pacheco was part of a group of students organized by Oakland Kids First, a youth leadership group, to attend the meeting. Discussion of the supper program was not on the board’s agenda, but students lined up to speak during the public comment period of the meeting. As each high schooler came to the podium for their allotted one minute, the others stood shoulder to shoulder beside them, holding homemade signs on white poster board. One sign, written in green and neon pink marker read: “What about the kids that don’t get fed at home?”
Another sign read: “Feed our bellies. We’re not full.”
And another: “Bring Back Supper. I’m hungry.”
Many students in Oakland rely on their school for meals. About 75 percent of the children in the Oakland Unified School District qualify for free and reduced-price lunch. Families need to apply and qualify based on guidelines that include household income and the number of people in the home. For example, a family may qualify if their monthly income is less than $3,870 for a household of four.
“I have noticed my friends are suffering from hunger and it makes me so upset,” said Perla Hernandez, 14, from Castlemont High School. “I feel so disgusted that I can’t believe that you guys don’t even think or worry about how many kids are starving and suffering. I demand for all of you to bring supper for kids and me.”
Several of the students talked about not being able to eat lunch because food lines are too long and they run out of time. Others said that they are so busy after school with sports and other activities that they don’t have an opportunity to eat until evening. “Young kids that stay after 8 for school programs, sports and other reasons don’t have a chance to get home, so they rely on supper to eat,” said Clarisa Garcia, 16, a soccer player at Castlemont High school.
The supper program provided hot meals for students across 32 schools in the district. Cutting it from the budget saved $1.4 million dollars. Students urged administrators to instead cut programs that they feel don’t directly affect student learning, like funds for the school district police department or administrative positions.
Pacheco submitted a petition with more than 1,400 signatures from students and parents urging the board to reinstate the supper program. Organizers said the students had been talking about it on campus and sending videos of themselves directly to board members to talk about the effect the cancellation of the program has had on them.
“I feel irritated and hangry right now cause y’all took the food away from us,” said Fremont High School student James Miller, using a term that refers to being so hungry that you are angry. “This makes you look bad because you expect us to do well in school and have good test scores and stuff. Us not getting fed means we’re in class hungry, thinking about food and we don’t have that energy.”
“I want you guys to think deep down about how many kids you are hurting and as you guys leave tonight,” Miller continued. “I want you to listen to Man in the Mirror by Michael Jackson and ‘make a change.’”
School Board President Aimee Eng (District 2) said board members were not able to speak during the public comment period and invited Mark Chavez, the new executive director of nutrition services, to speak to the room. Chavez walked up to the podium and turned to face the wall of students saying, “Your voice has been heard tonight.”
Chavez told the students that he has been on the job for less than a month and it is a priority for him to do something about the supper program. “It was 32 schools that were affected, but the vision that is being provided is to go district-wide,” he said. “There will be a balance to strike because we receive federal reimbursement and it is not part of the general fund. And we have to stay within the budget because we have to balance our food costs, our labor costs, and provide a good sound nutrition problem.”
He was interrupted by someone yelling, “Our kids are hungry!”
Earlier in the evening, Superintendent Kyla Johnson-Trammel had said Chavez was developing a proposal to replace the supper program with a “Super Snack Program,” which would replace the current small after-school snack, but the details still had to be worked out.
After all the students were done speaking, Lukas Brekke-Miesner, the executive director of Oakland Kids First, speaking outside the meeting, said the details that had been shared about the Super Snack Program indicated that it would not be sufficient for the students. He is concerned that the snack will be a cold, nutritionally-insufficient meal. “They want to be able to crank it out during the school day, send it to the sites and refrigerate it, so they don’t have to pay people to work longer and to make those deliveries further into the school day,” he said. “That would be required for a hot meal.”
Also during the meeting, school district nurses and teachers delivered to the school board more than 200 statements from parents, teachers and pediatricians about the condition of school health services. The district currently has 11 open positions for registered nurses. Special education teacher Sayuri Sakamoto told the board, “As a teacher, I have to stop instruction twice a day to administer medication.” She said another teacher had to call 911 twice in the past week because of students having seizures. “It’s about kids having medical emergencies at school. It’s very scary,” Sakamoto said.
After an extensive update from MetWest High School administrators and staff, the OUSD board voted to approve a plan to expand the high school by allowing a satellite campus on the Westlake Middle School Campus. MetWest would use a separate wing of Westlake that is currently not being used to increase the school’s enrollment and programs. The two would exist as separate schools with the opportunity to explore collaboration between them, MetWest administrators said.
Nana Xu, director of enrollment planning and policy, told the board that the district’s student population is 36,235, which she said is a 1.7 percent decline from last year and is potentially driven by the district’s early start of the school year. Last year, school board members agreed to move the first day of school one week earlier in August for several reasons, including closer alignment with the schedule for Peralta Colleges for students who might be enrolled in programs there.
Board Director Jody London (District 1) recalled that last year the board surveyed families when it was considering moving the first day of school to the second week of August. She said some parents told her they would not send their kids to school that first week and others threatened to pull out of OUSD all together if the early start date went through. The district intends to try one more year with school starting the second week of August. London said she wants to know more about whether the early start is the reason for the drop in enrollment. Enrollment numbers affect how much funding the state gives to the school district, and also how the district aligns staffing with student needs.
The next Oakland school board meeting will be on Wednesday, October 10.
Oakland North is an online news service produced by students at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and covering Oakland, California. Our goals are to improve local coverage, innovate with digital media, and listen to you–about the issues that concern you and the reporting you’d like to see in your community. Please send news tips to: firstname.lastname@example.org.