Skip to content

Audience members in City Hall to express concern over the propose dog park in Lake Merritt.

Astro Park doggy area decision delayed at city council meeting

on December 5, 2012

Oakland residents will have to wait another two weeks to find out if the city is one step closer to having a designated doggy area at the Lakeview park.

For almost 12 years, residents and city officials have debated whether to section off nearly 20,000 square feet of Astro Park at the corner of MacArthur Boulevard and Lakeshore Avenue to create a run for off-leash dogs or leave the area “green.” During Tuesday night’s council meeting, hundreds showed up wearing yellow and black paw prints on their shirts to show support for the park, while others brought signs that said “Not Sustainable.”

The dog park plan was originally introduced by councilwoman Nancy Nadel, and the project sponsor is the Oakland Dog Owner’s Group (ODOG), an advocacy group for more dog parks and off-leash spaces in the East Bay. The plan was originally introduced in 2002 as part of the city’s master plan to develop more activity around the Lake Merritt area.

But over years the proposed dog park has become a battleground between dog lovers and opponents who feel the location is not right for off-leash dogs. Some opponents of the plan believe the park will ruin the quality of the area and that the dogs will pose a danger to small children at the nearby tot lot.

During a May 2012 planning commission hearing, over 100 residents spoke, many bringing up concerns about how the park would affect the existing area, security issues, increased demand in parking at the park, and possible odors or health issues the park could cause. The commission denied the application for a conditional use permit at that time. ODOG appealed the committee’s decision. But at last night’s council meeting the council heard almost four hours of testimony about whether they should reverse the committee’s decision.

“I love dogs and I love Lake Merritt, but I don’t love this dog park,” said Maria Aldareti who was one of nearly 120 people who spoke during the meeting’s comment period. “We need to find more places in the city.”

“I would love my dogs to be social, but not at Astro, it’s too small,” Michelle Hutchins who told the council. “My dogs have been attacked, I have witnessed dog fights at dog parks and they are known not to be well maintained—they stink.”

But supporters say that with the nearest dog park almost two miles away, the new play area would provide a fenced area for owners to exercise their dogs and a section for both large and small dogs. Supporters of the plan also believe the park can bring the community together and will beautify the park.

“My dogs help me make life decisions,” said Nara Dahlbacka, who said she moved to Berkeley because of the lack of dog parks in Oakland. “This park would mean I could move back to Oakland. This [is] a smart growth idea.”

But because of the tough economic times, some councilmembers questioned where the funds would come from to build a fence for the dogs and maintain the site. The city would have to assume some of the costs of cleaning, making sure the park has proper signage, removing trash from the area and dealing with complaints.

According to a November report from Assistant City Administrator Fred Blackwell, if the city approves the area, it would pick up 40 percent of the total cost developing and maintain the park, using funds that have been previously allocated. The city’s partnership with ODOG would pay the remaining costs for the initial construction.

“Where is the money going to come from?” asked District 6 councilwoman Desley Brooks.

Ultimately, council members decided to delay the appeal vote to the next council meeting on December 18.


  1. […] Read the rest of the story by Ashley Griffin at Oakland North. […]

  2. Joe on December 6, 2012 at 10:00 am

    I’m an Oakland resident and long-time dog owner. While our city does have too few dog parks, I’m wondering more about the restrictive limits of on-leash walking in city parks. It would be great if the trail around Lake Merritt allowed this at least, while dogs could still be banned from the play areas off trail.

    I don’t like the location near the library for a dog run though. Pick somewhere else.

  3. livegreen on December 6, 2012 at 5:18 pm

    That’s a decent size plot of grass, mostly unused (except for the playground on the other side),
    so there should be enough room for everyone. There are dog parks in many urban areas (from
    Oakland to New York City), some near playgrounds. As long as the fencing and maintenance are
    ok then the park should be ok.

    That brings us to Desley Brooks question, which I think is more appropriate: Where’s the money going to come from? Can it be approved now for funding later? If not, maybe this should be implemented as the budget improves but after other services that have been cut are restored (safety, public works, etc.).

  4. Mr Freely on December 9, 2012 at 10:59 am

    There are too many dogs in Oakland, and too much dog poop.

    Quintuple the dog licenses fees, quadruple the fines for dog
    owners who unleash their dogs in public or fail to control their
    Set up a special prosecutor for dog infractions. Any cat
    owners who fail to control their cats will have the animal
    confiscated. Increase the budget for animal control and elect
    a dog catcher as Mayor .

    • Dee on December 11, 2012 at 5:03 pm

      Mr Freely, the people who pick up their dog crap? They’re the people who actually pay for licenses. The idiots who let their dogs go wherever are 9 times out of 10 don’t have a license, a leash, or a brain.

      • Mr Freely on December 12, 2012 at 9:05 am

        How do you know that?

  5. Therese on December 16, 2012 at 7:30 am

    Oakland has a few bigger problems than a dog park… Glad to see our city council is doing its finest in considering dog safety.

    • Mr Freely on December 30, 2012 at 9:35 am

      On behalf wildlife in Oakland, Nuts to the Dogs.

  6. Marty Price on December 17, 2012 at 9:36 pm

    Totally inapproriate place.20,000 ft from this area is a total dengration of the site. Let dog owners continue to walk their leased dogs around the lake. Most do pick up after there dogs but there is a large minority who do not.This little park already lost space when the freeway came through and ate up what most of you call Astro Park and the Splash Pad. So for us oldtimers who grewup in the area it was already bad enough giving up so much of the park to 580, but not to the dogs. There are so many varied activities in this park on any sunny weekend, lets keep it like that. Find another place over by Fairyland or that part of the park.

    • Mr Freely on December 30, 2012 at 9:38 am

      That is just so ignorant Marty.

  7. […] The city’s Planning Commission had previously decided to disallow the dog play area, but supporters, led by the group Oakland Dog Owners Group, or ODOG, filed an appeal in May, 2012. A council meeting earlier this month to consider the appeal took in nearly four hours of testimony from both dog park advocates and critics, but no vote was taken. […]

Oakland North welcomes comments from our readers, but we ask users to keep all discussion civil and on-topic. Comments post automatically without review from our staff, but we reserve the right to delete material that is libelous, a personal attack, or spam. We request that commenters consistently use the same login name. Comments from the same user posted under multiple aliases may be deleted. Oakland North assumes no liability for comments posted to the site and no endorsement is implied; commenters are solely responsible for their own content.

Photo by Basil D Soufi
Oakland North

Oakland North is an online news service produced by students at the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and covering Oakland, California. Our goals are to improve local coverage, innovate with digital media, and listen to you–about the issues that concern you and the reporting you’d like to see in your community. Please send news tips to:

Latest Posts

Scroll To Top